A commercial lease is a binding commitment for the full term, not just for as long as it suits you. That does not mean you are stuck. It means an early exit needs to be arranged, not assumed.

What happens if you just stop paying and leave

This is the expensive path. If you walk away, the landlord can end the lease and claim what it loses over the rest of the term, including any drop in rent when it re-lets and the costs of re-letting. A landlord claiming damages has to take reasonable steps to re-let, which reduces the bill but won't always wipe it out. Add legal fees on both sides and it is almost always more expensive than negotiating an exit properly.

LEASE ON TRIAL

Gumland v Duffy Bros: rent as an essential term

About $58,000 short on rent. The judgment: about $2.1 million.

Gumland Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Duffy Bros Fruit Market (Campbelltown) Pty Ltd [2008] HCA 1053 secondsLaw as at 18 October 2026

Read the transcript

A tenant fell about fifty-eight thousand dollars short on rent. The judgment it faced: about two point one million.

Duffy Bros leased a fruit and veg shop for fifteen years. The lease made paying rent on time essential, with damages for the whole term.

A subtenant paid half its rent and the tenant didn't cover it. Gumland, the new owner, ended the lease and sued, guarantors too.

The trial judge awarded about two point one million. The Court of Appeal cut it to about three hundred and sixty thousand.

The High Court restored the full award. Breach an essential term, and damages can cover the lost years, less what the landlord relets for.

The lesson. Check for clauses making rent essential before you sign, and pay every amount on time. Leases differ, so get advice.

Get your lease reviewed. theleasinglawyer.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

The four real ways out

  • Negotiated surrender. You and the landlord agree to end the lease, usually with a payment from you to compensate the landlord for the remaining term. It is often the fastest, cleanest exit if you can afford the number.
  • Assignment. You transfer the lease to a new tenant, commonly a buyer of your business. The landlord's consent is usually needed. Where the lease allows assignment with the landlord's consent, NSW law says that consent can't be unreasonably withheld. The landlord can ask for financial information about the incoming tenant. On a commercial lease it may also ask you to stay liable for a while. On a NSW retail lease the Act limits the reasons for refusing, sets a 28-day decision time, and can release you altogether if the disclosure steps are done right.
  • Subletting. You bring in a subtenant while you stay on the hook as the head tenant. Useful if you need flexibility rather than a clean break, but it does not remove your own liability under the lease.
  • A break clause, if you have one. Some leases include a right to end early at a set point, sometimes with a break fee attached. This only exists if it was negotiated in before signing, which is the strongest argument for asking for one on any longer-term lease.

Retail shop in NSW? The Act also gives you exit rights in some cases, such as a missing or defective disclosure statement (you have 6 months from entering into the lease to use that one), damage the landlord doesn't repair in a reasonable time after you ask in writing, or a demolition notice.

Selling the business almost always means assigning the lease. Landlord consent can take weeks, so start that process the moment a sale looks likely, not after contracts are exchanged with a settlement date already fixed.

Don't forget the incentive deed

If you received a rent-free period or a fitout contribution when you signed, the incentive deed usually requires some or all of it to be repaid if you leave before an agreed date. This sits separately from the lease itself, and people are regularly caught out because they only checked the lease.

If you are the landlord

A tenant coming to you early is an opportunity, not just a problem. A negotiated surrender or a properly vetted assignment can get you a new tenant faster and with less disruption than fighting over an exit. The commercial question is usually what number makes the exit worth agreeing to, and how quickly you can re-let once it happens.

The short version

An early exit is manageable if you deal with it head on: work out which of the four paths fits your situation, check the incentive deed as well as the lease, and get the numbers agreed in writing before you act. Do that and an early exit is a negotiation, not a dispute.