Most people sign a lease focused on the rent and the term. The make good clause sits near the back, written in a way that sounds harmless, and nobody thinks about it again until they are trying to leave. That is the wrong order. By the time you hand back the keys, the clause is fixed and your bargaining power is gone.
So deal with it now, while you still can.
What "make good" actually means
It is the part of the lease that sets out the condition you have to return the premises in at the end of the term. Simple idea. The cost lives in the detail, because "make good" can mean very different things depending on the wording.
Three versions show up most often:
- Clean and tidy. You hand the space back in good condition, fair wear and tear aside. The cheapest outcome for a tenant.
- Back to the condition at the start. You return the premises to how they were on day one. If you took an empty shell and fitted it out, you may have to rip the fitout out again.
- Back to base building, or to a shell. The most demanding version. Strip out everything, remove partitions, patch the ceiling, cap services, repaint. This is where the big numbers come from.
The wording is the whole game. "Good repair" and "the condition the premises were in at the commencement date" can be tens of thousands of dollars apart on the same shop. Read it as a number, not as legal furniture.
Why it costs so much
A full strip out is a building job. Demolition, waste removal, trades, making good the ceiling and floor, repainting, and often a fresh certificate or sign off before the landlord accepts the space back. On a fitted office or a food premises, that is real money, and it lands right when you are also paying to fit out your new place.
It gets worse when the clause is vague. A landlord with an open ended make good obligation and no agreed starting condition has every reason to ask for more, not less. You end up arguing about what the space looked like years ago, usually from a weaker position.
LEASE ON TRIAL
Tabcorp v Bowen: alterations without consent
A tenant rebuilt the foyer of a leased office without the landlord's written approval.
Read the transcript
A landlord's representative arrived for a site meeting about the foyer. The tenant's builders were already ripping it out.
Bowen leased an office building to Tabcorp for ten years. Big changes needed written approval, which couldn't be unreasonably refused.
The tenant replaced the foyer without approval. The landlord wanted it put back. The tenant said the building lost little value.
The trial judge awarded about thirty-five thousand dollars. The Full Court awarded one point three eight million, mostly rent for the restoration period.
The High Court upheld that. The landlord gets the cost of putting things back, where reinstatement is a reasonable course.
The lesson. Ask for written approval and wait for it. Rules can differ by state and lease, so get advice first.
Renovating? Get advice. theleasinglawyer.com.au
Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.
Deal with it before you sign
This is the part that matters. A make good clause is negotiable, and the cheapest time to fix it is the day you are still deciding whether to sign at all. There are several ways to keep the cost known and limited, and the right mix depends on your fitout and the deal. Working that out, and negotiating it, is what we do.
If you are the landlord
The mirror image applies. A clear make good clause protects you far better than a broad one that sounds tough but is hard to enforce. Vague clauses invite arguments, and arguments at the end of a lease delay your next tenant. Get the clause right at the start and you give yourself the best chance of getting the space back in a state you can actually re-let.
The short version
Make good is not a formality. It is a cost you agree to years before you pay it, usually without reading it as a cost at all. Treat the clause as a number and get advice on it before you sign. Do that, and you're far less likely to be caught by one of the nastiest surprises in commercial leasing.
Read next: bank guarantee vs bond · breaking a lease early · what we check before a tenant signs