An option to renew gives you the right to take another lease term when the current one ends. The key word is right. It is your choice, not the landlord's, and not an obligation on you. If the location works and the business is doing well, an option is genuinely valuable. It keeps you where your customers know to find you, and it stops the landlord moving you on at the end of the term. What you pay to stay depends on the rent clause, so check it early.

Valuable, and surprisingly easy to throw away.

How an option actually works

The lease sets a window before the end of the term during which you have to tell the landlord, in writing, that you want to take up the option. Do that correctly and on time and you get the further term. Miss it and the right can simply lapse.

Three things have to line up:

  • Timing. You have to give notice inside the window the lease specifies. Too early can be a problem. Too late is usually fatal.
  • Form. Notice generally has to be in writing and in the way the lease requires. A casual email or a chat with the agent may not count.
  • No breach. Options often only work if you are not in breach at the time, for example behind on rent. Landlords who would rather you left will look hard for a reason to say the option is not validly exercised. In NSW, though, a landlord who wants to rely on a breach to refuse your option has to tell you in writing within 14 days of your notice. You then have one month to ask the court for relief, so move quickly. Other states have their own rules, so check yours.

The deadline is the whole thing. The most common way tenants lose an option is by forgetting it exists. Diarise the exercise window the day you sign the lease, with a reminder months ahead, not weeks. This is the cheapest piece of risk management in your business.

LEASE ON TRIAL

Crown v Cosmopolitan Hotel: "looked after at renewal time"

Two restaurant tenants were told they would be "looked after at renewal time". Five years later, they had to leave.

Crown Melbourne Limited v Cosmopolitan Hotel (Vic) Pty Ltd [2016] HCA 2649 secondsLaw as at 22 October 2026

Read the transcript

Two Melbourne restaurant tenants were told they'd be looked after at renewal time. Five years on, they had to leave.

The leases ran five years, with no option. The tenants asked for ten years, or an option. The landlord said no.

The leases required a major fit-out, about four point six five million dollars. With no new lease, the tenants sued.

A tribunal awarded the tenants about one point six million. The appeals went both ways, up to the High Court.

Five judges to two, the High Court held the words were not a binding promise to offer a new lease.

Our tip. Need time to earn back a fit-out? Get the option in the lease. If you can't, budget on the term you have.

Get your lease reviewed. theleasinglawyer.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

LEASE ON TRIAL

ACCC v Berbatis: a new lease, on one condition

A shop sale depended on a new lease. The landlords' condition: the tenants release all claims against them.

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v CG Berbatis Holdings Pty Ltd [2003] HCA 1847 secondsLaw as at 23 October 2026

Read the transcript

A shop sale hung on a new lease. The landlords' condition: the tenants release all claims against them.

Two tenants in Western Australia were selling their shop. Their lease was ending, no option left. The buyer needed a new lease.

Their lawyer advised against signing. They signed, the sale went ahead, and the regulator, the ACCC, took the landlords to court.

The trial judge ruled against the landlords. The Full Federal Court reversed that, and the ACCC appealed to the High Court.

Four to one, the landlords won. A weak bargaining position wasn't a special disadvantage. The tenants had advice and chose rationally.

Our tip. Today's wider laws weren't tested here. Either way, bargain for an option when you sign the lease.

Get your lease reviewed. theleasinglawyer.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

This case was about an option to buy the land, not an option to renew a lease.

LEASE ON TRIAL

Perpetual Executors and Trustees Association of Australia Ltd v Russell: an option to buy that the owner never signed

Would you rely on an option to buy that only you had signed?

Perpetual Executors and Trustees Association of Australia Ltd v Russell [1931] HCA 749 secondsLaw as at 31 October 2026

Read the transcript

A lease with an option to buy was drawn up. The tenant signed it. The owner never did.

In nineteen nineteen, a Victorian owner let land for three years. The option to buy: six hundred pounds.

The owner died. On time, the tenant gave written notice and offered the price. It was refused. So why did he lose the land?

Victoria's Supreme Court let the tenant stay, but would not enforce his purchase. The executor took it to four High Court judges.

All four judges allowed the appeal. The majority said the option, once used, needed writing signed on the owner's side.

New South Wales has the same rule today. Without the owner's signature, you may not be able to enforce an option to buy.

We can review your lease. theleasinglawyer.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

LEASE ON TRIAL

Chan v Zacharia: two partners, one lease, one option

Should a former partner be free to take the lease?

Chan v Zacharia [1984] HCA 3658 secondsLaw as at 8 November 2026

Read the transcript

Two doctors ended their partnership. Then one of them asked the landlord for a new lease of their shared rooms, just for himself.

They leased consulting rooms in Adelaide for three years, with an option for two more, by written request in time.

Dr Zacharia asked Dr Chan to join in using the option. He declined, the deadline passed, and the landlord agreed to lease the rooms to Dr Chan.

The trial judge said any interest Dr Chan took in a new lease was held for the old partnership. The Full Court agreed, two to one. Then, the High Court.

Four of five judges agreed. A partner's duties last while the partnership is wound up. Dr Chan used his place as co-tenant and former partner to seek the new lease, so he held any interest in it on trust for the partnership, to be dealt with in its winding up, not for Dr Zacharia alone.

When partners hold a lease for their business, it can be a partnership asset. Their duties over it don't simply end when they part.

We can review your lease. theleasinglawyer.com.au

Dramatised from the published reasons of the High Court of Australia. General information, not legal advice.

The rent trap

An option tells you that you can stay. It often does not tell you clearly what you will pay to stay. The renewal rent is usually set one of three ways: a fresh market review, a fixed percentage increase, or a set figure written into the lease. A market review at renewal can land well above what you expect, and by the time you find out you may have limited room to move.

So read the rent mechanism before you exercise, not after. If it is a market review, get advice on timing and terms before you send the notice.

If you are the landlord

Options sit on your side of the ledger as a constraint. You have given the tenant the right to stay, so you cannot plan around vacant possession at the end of the term until the window passes. Keep clean records of the dates and the notice requirements, because a tenant's option only binds you if it is exercised properly.

The short version

An option to renew is worth real money and costs nothing to protect. Find the exercise window, diarise it the day you sign with plenty of lead time, check how the renewal rent is set, and give notice in writing exactly as the lease requires. Ignore the dates and you can lose your spot without anyone doing a single thing wrong.